Skip to Content

GST Refund Rejected for Procedural Lapses: Substance Over Form, Section 54 and Case Law

Why courts set aside GST refund rejections based on curable technical errors, and where the limits of that relief lie.
27 January 2026 by
H K Davra & Co.

Refunds are where the design of GST meets its administration. An exporter or a manufacturer with an inverted duty structure may be clearly entitled to a refund, yet the claim is rejected for a wrong category selected on the portal, a missing document, a mismatch in shipping bill data or an application filed a few days late. The tax is not in dispute; the paperwork is.

This article explains the refund framework under Section 54 of the CGST Act, 2017, the principle of substance over form as applied by the courts, which lapses are treated as curable and which are not, and practical steps for exporters and businesses filing refund claims.

Key points at a glance
  • Section 54 of the CGST Act governs refunds, generally within two years from the relevant date, through Form GST RFD-01.
  • Courts distinguish between substantive conditions (eligibility) and procedural requirements (manner of claiming); the latter should not defeat a genuine claim.
  • Before rejecting a claim, the officer must issue a deficiency memo or show cause notice and give an opportunity of being heard (Rule 90 and Rule 92).
  • From October 2025, 90% provisional refunds for zero-rated supplies and inverted duty structure claims are processed on a system-based risk assessment (CBIC Instruction No. 06/2025-GST).
  • Relief for procedural lapses is available only where the transaction is genuine and eligibility is otherwise established.

When is a GST refund available under Section 54?

The main situations in which a refund arises are:

  • export of goods or services, or supplies to SEZ units, without payment of tax (refund of unutilised ITC);
  • export of goods or services with payment of IGST;
  • accumulated ITC due to an inverted duty structure, where the tax rate on inputs is higher than on output supplies;
  • excess balance in the electronic cash ledger;
  • tax paid under the wrong head (for example, CGST and SGST instead of IGST) under Section 77;
  • refund arising from an appellate order, or tax paid on a supply that was not made.

The application is to be made within two years from the "relevant date" defined in the Explanation to Section 54, which differs by category, for example the date of export for goods, or the due date of the return for inverted duty claims. Refund of IGST paid on exports of goods is processed through the customs system on the basis of the shipping bill, which is deemed to be the refund application.

What does "substance over form" mean in refund cases?

The principle comes from a long line of decisions under earlier indirect tax laws. In Mangalore Chemicals and Fertilizers Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (1991), the Supreme Court distinguished between conditions that go to the root of an entitlement, which must be strictly complied with, and procedural or technical requirements, where non-compliance may be condoned if the substantive requirement is met. In Sambhaji v. Gangabai (2008), the Supreme Court described procedure as the handmaid of justice, not its mistress.

Applied to GST refunds, courts ask three questions:

  1. Is the taxpayer otherwise eligible, for example, is the export established?
  2. Is the lapse curable without prejudice to the revenue?
  3. Was the taxpayer given an opportunity to cure it before rejection?

Where the answers favour the taxpayer, High Courts have set aside rejections and directed fresh consideration. For instance, the Gujarat High Court in Amit Cotton Industries v. Principal Commissioner of Customs (2019) held that IGST refund on exported goods could not be withheld merely because the exporter had claimed drawback at a higher rate in the shipping bill, where the exporter was willing to repay the excess drawback.

Which lapses are treated as curable?

Type of lapseUsual judicial approachComment
Wrong refund category selected on the portalGenerally curableOfficer should consider the claim under the correct category if facts support it
Missing or incomplete documentCurable through deficiency memoRule 90(3) requires a deficiency memo (RFD-03) within 15 days
Clerical mismatch between invoice, shipping bill and GSTR-1Generally curableAmendment of GSTR-1 or correction with customs is usually the route
Rejection without show cause notice or hearingSet aside as violating Rule 92(3) and natural justiceOne of the most common grounds on which writs succeed
Application filed after the two-year periodMixedLimitation is treated strictly, but courts have excluded time lost in deficiency memos and the COVID period
Export not proved, or goods not actually exportedNot curableSubstantive condition; no refund

How is limitation treated?

Limitation is the area where procedural relief is most restricted. Courts generally treat the two-year period in Section 54 as binding, but several points operate in the taxpayer's favour:

  • COVID period: Following the Supreme Court's suo motu orders on limitation, Notification No. 13/2022-Central Tax excluded the period from 1 March 2020 to 28 February 2022 in computing the limitation for refund claims.
  • Deficiency memo: Where a fresh application is filed after a deficiency memo, Rule 90(3), as amended in 2022, excludes the period from the original filing to the date of the memo.
  • Tax paid under the wrong head: Rule 89(1A) allows the refund within two years from the date of payment of tax under the correct head.
  • Writ jurisdiction: In some cases High Courts have used their writ jurisdiction to allow refunds of tax that was never legally due, particularly for amounts paid under a mistake, though outcomes vary.
Practical point

A rejected application filed within time is often better than a perfect application filed late. Where documents are pending, filing within limitation and curing the deficiency on receipt of the memo usually preserves the claim.

Recent administrative changes: 90% provisional refunds

Section 54(6) has long allowed 90% of a refund for zero-rated supplies to be sanctioned provisionally. Following the recommendations of the 56th GST Council meeting in September 2025, Rule 91(2) of the CGST Rules was amended, and CBIC issued Instruction No. 06/2025-GST dated 3 October 2025. Under this, provisional refunds for zero-rated supplies, and also for inverted duty structure claims, are sanctioned on the basis of a system-generated risk evaluation. Low-risk claims are to be processed on a provisional basis, while claims flagged as high risk are examined in detail. Officers have been instructed not to withhold refunds on presumptive grounds alone.

This reduces delays for compliant taxpayers, but it also means that data consistency across GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, e-way bills and shipping bills directly affects the risk rating of a claim.

Practical checklist for refund claims

  1. Identify the correct refund category and the relevant date for limitation before preparing the claim.
  2. Reconcile invoice values, shipping bill or bill of export details, and GSTR-1 entries; correct errors in GSTR-1 amendments before filing.
  3. For services, keep the foreign inward remittance evidence (FIRC or bank realisation certificate) ready.
  4. For inverted duty claims, compute the eligible amount using the Rule 89(5) formula and exclude input services and capital goods.
  5. Respond to deficiency memos and show cause notices within the time allowed, with a clear reconciliation.
  6. If a claim is rejected without a hearing or on a technical ground, record the defect and consider appeal or writ remedies promptly.

Frequently Asked Questions on GST Refund Rejection

Can a GST refund be rejected for a minor procedural error?

Courts have held that where eligibility is established, a genuine refund should not be rejected for curable procedural errors, and the taxpayer should be given a chance to correct them.

Is a show cause notice required before rejecting a refund?

Yes. Rule 92(3) of the CGST Rules requires a notice in Form RFD-08 and an opportunity of being heard before a refund is rejected in whole or in part.

What is the time limit for claiming a GST refund?

Generally two years from the relevant date under Section 54. The period from 1 March 2020 to 28 February 2022 is excluded, and time spent in a deficiency memo is excluded under Rule 90(3).

What happens if the wrong refund category is selected?

The usual remedy is to withdraw and refile under the correct category within limitation. Where that is not possible, courts have in several cases directed the officer to consider the claim on merits.

Are 90% provisional refunds available for inverted duty structure claims?

Yes. After the Rule 91(2) amendment and CBIC Instruction No. 06/2025-GST, provisional refunds of up to 90% are available for zero-rated and inverted duty claims assessed as low-risk by the system.

Does substance over form help if the export itself is not proved?

No. Proof of export or zero-rated supply is a substantive condition. Relief is available only for lapses in the manner of claiming, not for gaps in eligibility.

Conclusion

The courts have consistently held that refund provisions exist to neutralise tax on exports and on credit accumulated for structural reasons, not to generate revenue from procedural slips. A refund that is clearly due should not be lost for a wrong category, a clerical mismatch or a rejection without hearing.

That said, the principle protects only genuine claims supported by records. Filing within limitation, clean reconciliations and timely responses to deficiency memos remain the most reliable way to secure refunds, particularly now that provisional sanction depends on system-based risk scores.

Facing a GST dispute or blocked credit?

H K Davra & Co. advises on GST input tax credit, refunds, notices and appeals.

Talk to us

This article is intended for general information and knowledge sharing only and does not constitute professional advice or solicitation of any kind. Provisions are summarised as of September 2026. Readers should refer to the relevant provisions, regulations and judicial pronouncements for their specific facts.

H K Davra & Co. 27 January 2026
Share this post
Archive
ITC Denial for Supplier Default under GST: Section 16(2)(c), Suncraft Energy and Case Law
When GST credit can and cannot be denied to a buyer because the supplier did not file returns or pay tax, and how to defend it.