Skip to Content

ITC Denial for Supplier Default under GST: Section 16(2)(c), Suncraft Energy and Case Law

When GST credit can and cannot be denied to a buyer because the supplier did not file returns or pay tax, and how to defend it.
20 January 2026 by
H K Davra & Co.

A buyer pays the full invoice value, including GST, to a registered supplier, receives the goods and records the purchase. Months later, the GST officer issues a notice proposing to deny the Input Tax Credit (ITC) because the supplier did not file GSTR-3B or did not deposit the tax it collected. The buyer did nothing wrong, yet is asked to pay the same tax again, with interest and possibly a penalty.

This article explains the statutory condition in Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act, 2017 that gives rise to such demands, how High Courts and the Supreme Court have approached ITC denial for supplier default, the limits of that protection, and the documents a buyer should keep. It is intended for finance teams, procurement heads and GST practitioners handling ITC mismatch notices.

Key points at a glance
  • Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act allows ITC only if the tax charged has actually been paid to the Government by the supplier.
  • Courts have held that ITC should not be denied to a bona fide recipient merely because the supplier defaulted, without first examining the facts and pursuing the supplier.
  • In Suncraft Energy (Calcutta High Court, 2023), the department's appeal was dismissed by the Supreme Court in December 2023.
  • The Supreme Court in Shanti Kiran India (2025), a Delhi VAT case, again protected bona fide purchasers where there was no collusion.
  • Protection is not automatic: the buyer carries the burden of proving that the transaction was genuine (Ecom Gill Coffee Trading, Supreme Court, 2023).

What does Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act require?

Section 16(2) lists the conditions a registered person must satisfy to claim ITC. Broadly, the recipient must:

  • possess a tax invoice or debit note (clause (a));
  • have the details of the invoice furnished by the supplier in GSTR-1 and communicated in GSTR-2B (clause (aa), inserted from 1 January 2022);
  • have received the goods or services (clause (b));
  • ensure that the tax charged has been actually paid to the Government, in cash or through utilisation of admissible ITC (clause (c)); and
  • have furnished its own return under Section 39 (clause (d)).

Clause (c) is the source of most disputes. The buyer has no control over whether the supplier deposits the tax, and cannot usually verify the supplier's cash ledger. Rule 37A of the CGST Rules adds a procedural layer: if the supplier has not filed GSTR-3B for the relevant period by 30 September of the following financial year, the recipient must reverse the ITC, and may re-avail it once the supplier files the return.

Why do buyers receive ITC denial notices for supplier default?

Most notices arise from system-driven comparisons between the ITC claimed in GSTR-3B and the data in GSTR-2A/2B, or from information that the supplier has become non-filer, had its registration cancelled with retrospective effect, or was found non-existent. Typical triggers include:

  • the supplier uploaded the invoice in GSTR-1 but did not file GSTR-3B or pay the tax;
  • the supplier collected GST from the buyer but did not deposit it;
  • the supplier's registration was cancelled from a back date covering the invoice period;
  • the ITC in GSTR-3B exceeds the amount reflected in GSTR-2B.

In many such cases the department proceeds directly against the recipient under Section 73 or 74, without first attempting recovery from the supplier.

What have the courts held on ITC denial for supplier default?

Suncraft Energy (Calcutta High Court, 2023)

In Suncraft Energy Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner, State Tax, the Calcutta High Court set aside an ITC reversal where the department had not taken any action against the defaulting supplier and had not examined whether the recipient's claim was genuine. The court directed that the recipient should be proceeded against only in exceptional cases, such as collusion or where the supplier is missing or the business has closed. The Supreme Court dismissed the department's appeal in December 2023.

Arise India (Delhi High Court, 2017)

Under the Delhi VAT Act, the Delhi High Court in Arise India Ltd. v. Commissioner of Trade and Taxes read down Section 9(2)(g), holding that denying credit to a purchasing dealer who had acted in good faith, for the selling dealer's default, violated Article 14 of the Constitution. The Supreme Court dismissed the department's appeal in 2018.

Shanti Kiran India (Supreme Court, 2025)

In Commissioner of Trade and Tax, Delhi v. Shanti Kiran India (P) Ltd. (2025), again under the Delhi VAT Act, the Supreme Court upheld the High Court's view that a purchasing dealer who had bought goods from registered dealers against tax invoices, and paid tax to them, could not be denied credit merely because the sellers failed to deposit the tax, in the absence of fraud or collusion. Although these are VAT decisions, the reasoning is regularly applied to GST disputes because the value-added design is the same.

The other side: Ecom Gill Coffee Trading (Supreme Court, 2023)

In State of Karnataka v. Ecom Gill Coffee Trading Pvt. Ltd. (2023), the Supreme Court held that the purchasing dealer claiming credit must prove the genuineness of the transaction, including the identity of the seller, actual physical movement of goods and payment. Producing invoices and proof of payment through bank alone was held insufficient. This decision sets the evidentiary bar that a bona fide purchaser must meet.

Practical point

Practical point: The judicial protection is for the bona fide recipient. Where the supplier is a paper entity, the goods never moved, or the invoice was issued without supply, courts have consistently upheld ITC denial and, in appropriate cases, penalties under Section 122.

When will a buyer succeed, and when will it not?

FactorSupports the buyerWeakens the buyer
Supplier statusActive GSTIN on the invoice date, with filing historyRegistration cancelled ab initio; supplier non-existent at address
Movement of goodsE-way bill, lorry receipt, weighbridge slip, gate inward entryNo transport evidence, or vehicle details do not match
PaymentFull value including GST paid through bank, within normal credit periodCash payments, circular funds, or amounts returned to the buyer
Use of goodsGoods reflected in stock and consumption records or onward salesNo trace of goods in stock registers
Department's actionNo recovery attempted from supplierSupplier investigated and found to be issuing invoices without supply

How should a buyer respond to an ITC denial notice?

  1. Obtain the complete basis of the demand, including the GSTR-2A/2B comparison or investigation report relied upon.
  2. Compile evidence of genuineness: purchase order, tax invoice, e-way bill, transport documents, goods receipt note, stock entries and bank statement showing payment of the invoice value including GST.
  3. Establish the supplier's registration status on the invoice date using the GST portal's search facility, and keep a dated copy.
  4. Point out in the reply whether any proceedings have been initiated against the supplier, and request that recovery be first attempted from the supplier.
  5. Rely on the relevant judgments, distinguishing them from cases involving fake invoices.
  6. Where the supplier later files GSTR-3B, re-avail the credit under Rule 37A and bring this to the officer's attention.
  7. If an adverse order is passed, consider the appellate route, now including the GST Appellate Tribunal, or a writ where the order ignores the settled principles.

Practical due diligence on suppliers

Judicial relief is available only after a dispute, which costs time and money. Preventive controls reduce exposure:

  • verify GSTIN status and return filing frequency before onboarding a supplier and periodically thereafter;
  • match purchase registers with GSTR-2B every month and follow up on missing invoices;
  • consider withholding the GST component of payment, or including a contractual indemnity, for suppliers with irregular filing;
  • keep transport and receipt evidence for goods, and service delivery evidence (reports, emails, timesheets) for services;
  • track Rule 37A reversals and re-availment in a register.

Frequently Asked Questions on ITC Denial for Supplier Default

Can GST ITC be denied if the supplier did not pay tax to the Government?

Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act makes payment of tax by the supplier a condition for ITC. However, courts have held that a bona fide buyer should not be denied credit mechanically without examining the facts and first proceeding against the defaulting supplier.

What did the Supreme Court decide in Suncraft Energy?

In December 2023 the Supreme Court dismissed the department's appeal against the Calcutta High Court judgment, which had held that the recipient should be pursued only in exceptional cases after action against the supplier.

Is a bank payment enough to prove a genuine purchase?

No. In Ecom Gill Coffee Trading (2023), the Supreme Court held that invoices and bank payments alone are not enough; the buyer should also prove the seller's identity and the actual movement of goods.

What is Rule 37A of the CGST Rules?

Rule 37A requires a recipient to reverse ITC where the supplier has not filed GSTR-3B for the relevant period by 30 September of the following financial year. The credit can be re-availed once the supplier files the return and pays the tax.

Does retrospective cancellation of the supplier's registration affect the buyer's ITC?

It is often used as a ground for denial. Where the supplier was registered on the invoice date and the transaction is proved, courts have in several cases held that retrospective cancellation alone does not justify denying ITC to a bona fide buyer.

Do VAT-era judgments apply to GST?

They are not binding interpretations of the CGST Act, but courts have applied the same reasoning under GST because both are value-added taxes with similar credit conditions.

Conclusion

Section 16(2)(c) remains on the statute book, and the department continues to issue demands based on supplier default. The courts, including the Supreme Court in Suncraft Energy and Shanti Kiran India, have made clear that ITC should not be denied mechanically to a buyer who has paid tax and received supplies in good faith. At the same time, Ecom Gill Coffee Trading places the burden of proving genuineness on the buyer.

In practice, the outcome of these disputes depends on the quality of the buyer's records. Supplier checks, monthly GSTR-2B reconciliation and complete movement and payment evidence are what turn a sound legal principle into a successful defence.

Facing a GST dispute or blocked credit?

H K Davra & Co. advises on GST input tax credit, refunds, notices and appeals.

Talk to us

This article is intended for general information and knowledge sharing only and does not constitute professional advice or solicitation of any kind. Provisions are summarised as of September 2026. Readers should refer to the relevant provisions, regulations and judicial pronouncements for their specific facts.

H K Davra & Co. 20 January 2026
Share this post
Archive
Section 40(a)(ia): 30% TDS Disallowance, Later-Year Relief and Section 35(b)(i) of the New Act
When non-deduction or late payment of TDS triggers the 30% disallowance, how it is allowed back, and the 2025 Act position.